---
title: Milburn Review Asks Employers to Stop Demanding Experience for Entry-Level Jobs
description: The Milburn review asks large employers to give 10% of entry-level jobs to Neets and drop needless experience requirements. The CBI and Halo respond.
author: Darie Nani (Editor-in-Chief)
date: 2026-11-17T17:52:37.594Z
updated: 2026-11-17T17:52:37.619Z
canonical: https://www.sovereignmagazine.com/article/milburn-review-employers-entry-level-jobs
image: https://cdn.nanimediahouse.com/pexels-side-view-of-senior-foreman-in-eyeglasses-showing-to-trainee-3846262.jpg
categories: Economy, Social Impact
content_type: News
region: United Kingdom
publication: Sovereign Magazine
about:
  - type: Person
    name: Alan Milburn
    description: Former Labour health secretary commissioned in November 2025 to lead an independent review into why so many young people in the UK are not in education, employment or training. His interim report was published in May 2026 and his final report in November 2026.
    jobTitle: Author of the government-commissioned Young People and Work review
    sameAs:
      - https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Alan_Milburn
---

Large employers should aim to give one in ten of their entry-level vacancies to young people who are out of work, education and training, under the final report Alan Milburn published on Tuesday 17th November. The report also asks firms to drop experience requirements that a first job does not need, and offers more than £1 billion a year in public money to make hiring young people pay.

Much of the attention before publication went on what the review means for disability benefits for under-25s, which [we set out this morning](https://www.sovereignmagazine.com/article/neet-young-people-disability-gap-milburn-review). The final report, [From a Welfare State to a Working State](https://www.gov.uk/government/publications/from-a-welfare-state-to-a-working-state-a-new-settlement-for-the-next-generation), puts as much weight on employers. Milburn calls for "a new bargain" with business and says that without a change in direction, "rebuilding the first rung will not happen."

Business responses on Tuesday welcomed the aim. The CBI says the cost of hiring is the main obstacle, while the founder of one Ipswich software company says too many firms still want young recruits to arrive already trained.

## Large Employers Are Asked to Give 10% of Entry-Level Jobs to Neets

The employer plan is called First Chance, a movement Milburn's review built with employers during the past year. It asks firms for three things: more genuine first jobs, more apprenticeships for young people and much wider access to work experience. Large private employers that join would set and publish their own targets, including, where possible, making 10% of entry-level vacancies available to young people who are Neet.

> "Unnecessary experience requirements, inaccessible assessment and opaque criteria should not turn the first job into a reward for already having had one."
> — Alan Milburn, From a Welfare State to a Working State

The report goes further on recruitment. It says large employers should find a way to reply to applicants they turn down, because "all too often unsuccessful candidates currently face a wall of silence."

The public sector would be held to the same 10% figure. Every government department and major public employer would publish a three-year plan for youth hiring, the Civil Service would aim for at least 11% of its entry-level workforce to be aged 16 to 24 by 2032, almost double the current share, and large NHS employers would guarantee interviews to Neet applicants who meet the essential criteria. Government contracts would carry the same expectation: youth employment would become a required social value test for projects above £5 million, and contracts above £50 million, along with major defence, energy and infrastructure work, would have to include firm youth hiring commitments.

First Chance is voluntary for private firms. The review says government should now work with employers to roll it out across the country, and its timetable has it launching during 2027.

## A Software Founder Says Incentives Fail if Firms Still Ask for Experience

Paul Hamilton, founder and chief executive of Halo, an Ipswich company that sells business software in competition with Salesforce and ServiceNow, says the report's proposals are welcome but will not work on their own.

"The Milburn review sets out some welcome proposals to help more young people into work, but it won't solve the NEETs crisis if employers still ask for years of experience for entry-level jobs," Hamilton said. "Businesses need to be willing to give young people a chance instead of expecting them to arrive fully trained."

Halo says around 95% of its employees have never worked anywhere else and that their average age is 24. The company hires for attitude rather than experience and trains staff itself. It also asks everyone to work from the office, a choice Hamilton links directly to young recruits.

"The shift towards remote and hybrid working has also made it harder for younger employees to learn from experienced colleagues," he said. "The government can encourage businesses to hire, but employers have a responsibility to turn those opportunities into lasting careers."

## The State Would Spend £1.1 Billion a Year Helping Firms Hire Young People

The review accepts that cost is part of the problem. It asks government to commit not to make hiring young people any more expensive, to publish a Youth Employment Cost Index every two years showing how its decisions affect the youth jobs market, and to keep telling the Low Pay Commission to weigh youth employment when it sets the pace of minimum wage rises.

On National Insurance, Milburn rejects an immediate cut across the board as a poor use of several billion pounds. He proposes instead that, once the public finances allow, employer contributions for workers aged 21 to 24 come down over five years, starting in retail and hospitality, by doubling the point at which they become payable from £5,000 to £10,000.

The bigger change is in direct payments to employers. Firms would receive £3,000 for taking on any young person who has been Neet for six months, a payment opened up to the 314,000 young people in that position who claim no benefits at all. A further £2,000 would go to employers hiring a young person facing much greater barriers, such as a care leaver or a disabled young person, and another £2,000 to businesses with fewer than 50 staff. The payment for creating an apprenticeship would rise to £2,500 and be extended to firms that pay the Apprenticeship Levy.

The review puts the package at around £1.1 billion a year once it is running in full, more than double what government now spends helping employers take on young people, and expects it to create about 170,000 extra jobs and apprenticeships.

Rain Newton-Smith, chief executive of the CBI, called the review "a once in a generation chance to turn around opportunity for young people" and said businesses are willing to help. She said the high cost of hiring and weak demand are taking a toll on young people.

"Firms are struggling to absorb rising employment costs at the same time as consumers worried about the cost of living are cutting back," she said. "We welcome the proposal to cut employer NICs for young workers. Making it more affordable for firms to create entry-level roles would help young people get that vital first foothold in the labour market."

## Business Wants the Guaranteed Hours Rules Written With Entry-Level Jobs in Mind

The review asks ministers to treat youth employment as a main consideration when they finalise the new guaranteed hours rules, and to take a cautious approach that limits any harm to seasonal and temporary work. It also proposes a Youth Opportunity Test, under which changes to public policy would be assessed for their effect on young people's chances of work or study.

Newton-Smith made the same point. "Getting the landing zone right on measures such as guaranteed hours will be important so that reforms improve security for workers without inadvertently reducing the entry-level opportunities the review is seeking to create," she said.

## Apprenticeships for Under-25s Would Be Funded in Full

Milburn calls apprenticeships the largest education and skills priority in the report. He wants the number of young people completing one to double over the next decade, with annual starts for under-25s rising towards 270,000 and around 35% of young people starting a good apprenticeship by the age of 25 by 2036. The report also proposes 25,000 places on courses that prepare young people for an apprenticeship.

To pay for it, the Treasury would stop taking a share of apprenticeship funding from the Growth and Skills Levy, apprenticeships for under-25s would be paid for in full from the levy, and government would put less money into apprenticeships for people over 25.

The CBI wants older workers kept in the system. "Government should be looking to strengthen business confidence in the system so firms can continue investing in both young people and existing workers," Newton-Smith said. "After recent rounds of defunding, the proposed co-investment rule risks further weakening businesses' confidence in apprenticeships."

## Existing Claimants Would Move to the New Benefit System After a Transition

The final report confirms the benefit changes trailed before publication. Under-25s would receive a single Youth Allowance at the standard Universal Credit rate, with a higher rate for those living independently, in place of the Universal Credit health element. The Personal Independence Payment would be replaced for this age group by an Additional Cost Allowance, awarded after an assessment led by healthcare professionals, and a new Severe and Complex Needs Insurance would pay a higher long-term income to young people who are unlikely ever to be able to work.

The report says the new system would cover young people already claiming as well as new claimants. People claiming for the first time would join it in stages from within the lifetime of this Parliament, if the legislation passes, and existing claimants would move across "following a personalised, time-limited transition." Milburn accepts the changes "could mean some people get less financial support at the beginning of their benefit claim than under the current system."

The review's modelling says the reforms would help around 440,000 young people into lasting work by 2036. Welfare savings would begin in 2029/30 and reach £3.6 billion a year by 2036/37.

## The Government Has Not Yet Said Which Recommendations It Will Adopt

The government had not published its formal response by Tuesday afternoon, and the report itself says ministers should confirm their plans in that response. Milburn's timetable has £500 million spent during 2027 to start building a Youth Opportunity Service in every area, launch First Chance and expand the grant for employers, while the welfare changes go through Parliament.

Some of what the report asks of employers does not depend on that timetable. Dropping a requirement for experience from a job advert, or replying to the candidates who did not get the job, needs no new law.

## FAQ

**Q: What is the current situation with the Neet crisis in the UK?**
Nearly one million young people aged 16 to 24 in the UK are not in education, employment or training, around 13% of the age group. The Milburn review sets a goal of cutting that rate to around 5% by 2036. It also points out that nearly 57,000 16 and 17-year-olds in England are Neet, even though young people in England are required by law to stay in education or training until 18.

**Q: Why is Gen Z not getting hired?**
In the UK, young people are competing for fewer entry-level jobs. The sectors that hire the most young people, retail and hospitality, have faced higher employment costs, and the CBI says weak consumer demand is also holding hiring back. The Milburn review adds that many employers ask for experience a first job should not need, which shuts out applicants who have never worked.

**Q: What does Neet mean?**
Neet stands for not in education, employment or training. In the UK it usually refers to young people aged 16 to 24. It includes young people who are looking for work and those who are not, for example because of illness, disability or caring responsibilities.
